A friend disagreed with my last post on the point about what
Atheism is and is not.
So, to explain, let me take a step back. Most mainstream
& moderate* religious people would have a statement of what they do (and do
not) believe of the form:
Given that there is,
and can, be no evidence either way, and in the very real knowledge that I could
be wrong, I have chosen to [specifics].
Examples of [specifics] would be along the lines of “follow
[this version] of Christianity”, “follow [this version] of Islam”, etc.
Now we get to Agnosticism. Agnostics, as religious people
understand them, generally tend to not have any beliefs for or against the
metaphysical. They’re simply not convinced. Thus their statement would be:
Given that there is and
can be no evidence either way, and in the very real knowledge that I could be
wrong, I have chosen to neither believe nor disbelieve, reserving judgement
unless something should change my mind.
And what do the religious folks think Atheism is? Well, it’s
one step beyond agnosticism, based on older traditions, and would be along the
lines of:
Given that there is
and can be no evidence either way, and in the very real knowledge that I could
be wrong, I have chosen to believe that there is nothing to the metaphysical.
So far so good. Next we have the modern version of Atheists,
who insist that they don’t disbelieve, they just don’t believe . When asked,
they would typically say that sufficient evidence would (quite logically)
change their mind. Or, to put it another way, they neither believe not
disbelieve, reserving judgement unless something should change their mind.
These Atheists would typically fall to the dictionary's definition
of Agnosticism; “The belief that knowledge of god and/or the metaphysical is
impossible”. By that definition, the statement of beliefs used above would make
almost everyone Agnostic by definition, thus not a useful definition.
However, English is descriptively defined, and thus we need
not stick to that definition if it is not how it is being used in practice. And
this is where there is a problem. What a large majority of “Atheists” believe
(or not) these days is exactly the same what the religious folks these days
think of as Agnosticism.
And thus we have the problem in that what the religious folk
understand as "Agnosticism" and "Atheism" is different from
that understood by modern Atheists and some scholars.
*For those who are bound to ask, the extremists claim
certain knowledge of the metaphysical, which is impossible by definition. Thus
they either do not understand the things they say, do not understand the way the world works, or
are, by definition, delusional. Either way they (again by definition) lack
faith.