Tuesday, 24 January 2017

Why we don’t need to engage the unreasonable



There is more than one meaning to the word “offensive”. The first means something that upsets people. The second is an actual attack.

Swearing may be offensive (1), but punching someone is offensive (2). Offensive (2) is only ever justified by offensive (2), when you didn’t start the fight.

Here’s the thing: it is possible to use words and laws to commit an act which is offensive (2). You want to discriminate, remove people’s rights & freedoms, etc; that’s offensive (2). It’s likely ALSO offensive (1), but that’s beside the point, nobody gets to conflate the two meanings.

You are expected to act like a grownup. Society reasonably expects you to behave with civility, and in return you will be treated with civility. As soon as you start being offensive (2), you break that social contract. This is taught to us as children. We’re given those rules as children so we know to follow them as adults. 

You don’t get to attack someone and expect that nobody will fight back, whether with fists or with a swift call to the police. That’s not how the world works. And after all, a person is so far from civility that they’re attacking some portion of society unprovoked, what hope do we have of combating them with a simple argument?



I’ll fight for your right to say these offensive (2) things, sure. I’ll still think you’re an idiot. And I’ll not be surprised or sympathetic if you receive a condign punch to the head.

Saturday, 21 January 2017

Politically Awkward




There's a lot of chat back and forth these days about "political correctness", but a if you look at the arguments made about it, it becomes clear that there is more than one meaning being used. This does not help, for reasons I've talked about before. There are three broad camps arguing about this stuff, each with their own use of the term.

The first group use "politically correct" and "politically incorrect" as a label for the way language s used. "Politically incorrect" is language with is either deliberately bigoted and offensive ("nigger", "faggot", "paki", etc) and/or that which involves arguments underscored by bigotry rather than facts. "Politically correct" language, meanwhile, is that which is not designed to be offensive. It may offend someone, but that is not by design. This first group recognise that using certain language will cause offence and thus lead to the user being rejected by a society which holds adults to certain standards. Society at large reasonably expects to know that acting like a bigot will get you ostracised, since you will have been taught this growing up.

The second group see nothing wrong with the use of the bigoted language the first group label as "politically incorrect". They are want to make use of arguments underscored by opinions contrary to logic and demonstrable facts. They have a problem with society rejecting them and their arguments. They want not only to be able to speak their minds freely, but to have no negative social consequences for doing so. This group thus label the negative social reaction to their bigoted language as "political correctness". They do not believe that they should be held to the standards of behaviour that society as a whole sets for adults.

The third group are somewhere between the first two groups. They are upset at being pressured to use the language the first group declares "politically correct". Not necessarily because they want to use the bigoted language, but because they value freedom of speech, and besides, it allows you to identify the actual bigots. These people label restrictions on what language is banned and/or required by officials (of companies, governments, regulators, etc) to be "political correctness".

So, next time someone is talking about political correctness, stop and think, what are they REALLY talking about. It may not be the sort of thing you mean by the same words.