Thursday, 2 February 2017

A Question for "Leave" Voters!



Brexit is going ahead, that bit of it is basically a done deal. What we need to do now is come together and make sure that Theresa May and her team give us the KIND of Brexit the people who voted want. What does it need to do to be accepted by Miss May's employers, the British people?

Now, a lot of people voted for Brexit for a lot of different reasons, but I've put together a list of the most common ones, into a litmus test of what they seem to want from the Brexit. Since Ms May has twelve fundamental aims in her plan, I've framed this as twelve points.

So, here I ask: If you are a Remainer, simply pass this around. If you're a Leaver, tell me where this is right or wrong.

1. Parliamentary sovereignty to verifiably increase.
2. Ensure that every person given governmental power has been elected by the British people.
3. Government to guarantee free and comprehensive publicly-run health care for all, forever. Per-capita NHS spending in real terms to increase in the short term, and not to ever diminish in the future*.
4. Real term minimum wages to increase in the short term, and not to ever diminish in the future*.
5. Per-capita non-NHS public services spending in real terms to increase in the short term, and not to ever diminish in the future*.
6. Taxation rates on goods corporation tax, and on incomes of workers earning up to twice the national average or less to never increase, and never be as much or higher than any corporate tax rate, non-dom-rate, etc.
7. Government to guarantee full, comfortable,  and comprehensive retirement and pension from the age of sixty for all British citizens. This age is only allowed to lower, not increase.*
8. Housing stock in real terms to increase to 1970's levels, and never be allowed to diminish.*
9 Compensation Culture, AKA "Political Correctness" to end.**
10. Bank and Corporation bailouts to end, being replaced with bailouts to affected citizens.
11. Zero hour and short-term contracts to be made illegal, so people can have proper jobs for life. Government to guarantee worthwhile, meaningful, and fulfilling full-time employment for every adult British citizen.*
12. No deployed soldier, doctor, nurse, paramedic, coast-guard, fire-fighter, or teacher, to ever earn less than any member of the government. We need to offer good wages to attract the best people.*


*While many people cited "reducing immigration" as a need, on further questioning, this was almost always a means to an end, while having nothing against the immigrants themselves. These points reflect those ends, and this the government may achieve this by immigration reduction or by some other means as necessary.

**While many people cited "ending political correctness" as a need, on further questioning it becomes clear that the vast majority are using this term as a synonym for the phenomenon known as "compensation culture", and no as some other meaning.

Tuesday, 24 January 2017

Why we don’t need to engage the unreasonable



There is more than one meaning to the word “offensive”. The first means something that upsets people. The second is an actual attack.

Swearing may be offensive (1), but punching someone is offensive (2). Offensive (2) is only ever justified by offensive (2), when you didn’t start the fight.

Here’s the thing: it is possible to use words and laws to commit an act which is offensive (2). You want to discriminate, remove people’s rights & freedoms, etc; that’s offensive (2). It’s likely ALSO offensive (1), but that’s beside the point, nobody gets to conflate the two meanings.

You are expected to act like a grownup. Society reasonably expects you to behave with civility, and in return you will be treated with civility. As soon as you start being offensive (2), you break that social contract. This is taught to us as children. We’re given those rules as children so we know to follow them as adults. 

You don’t get to attack someone and expect that nobody will fight back, whether with fists or with a swift call to the police. That’s not how the world works. And after all, a person is so far from civility that they’re attacking some portion of society unprovoked, what hope do we have of combating them with a simple argument?



I’ll fight for your right to say these offensive (2) things, sure. I’ll still think you’re an idiot. And I’ll not be surprised or sympathetic if you receive a condign punch to the head.

Saturday, 21 January 2017

Politically Awkward




There's a lot of chat back and forth these days about "political correctness", but a if you look at the arguments made about it, it becomes clear that there is more than one meaning being used. This does not help, for reasons I've talked about before. There are three broad camps arguing about this stuff, each with their own use of the term.

The first group use "politically correct" and "politically incorrect" as a label for the way language s used. "Politically incorrect" is language with is either deliberately bigoted and offensive ("nigger", "faggot", "paki", etc) and/or that which involves arguments underscored by bigotry rather than facts. "Politically correct" language, meanwhile, is that which is not designed to be offensive. It may offend someone, but that is not by design. This first group recognise that using certain language will cause offence and thus lead to the user being rejected by a society which holds adults to certain standards. Society at large reasonably expects to know that acting like a bigot will get you ostracised, since you will have been taught this growing up.

The second group see nothing wrong with the use of the bigoted language the first group label as "politically incorrect". They are want to make use of arguments underscored by opinions contrary to logic and demonstrable facts. They have a problem with society rejecting them and their arguments. They want not only to be able to speak their minds freely, but to have no negative social consequences for doing so. This group thus label the negative social reaction to their bigoted language as "political correctness". They do not believe that they should be held to the standards of behaviour that society as a whole sets for adults.

The third group are somewhere between the first two groups. They are upset at being pressured to use the language the first group declares "politically correct". Not necessarily because they want to use the bigoted language, but because they value freedom of speech, and besides, it allows you to identify the actual bigots. These people label restrictions on what language is banned and/or required by officials (of companies, governments, regulators, etc) to be "political correctness".

So, next time someone is talking about political correctness, stop and think, what are they REALLY talking about. It may not be the sort of thing you mean by the same words.

Wednesday, 5 October 2016

Resolving the Gordian Knot of Brexit



Brexit is, of course, controversial. Just over a third of our citizens voted for it, and won just over half the vote. So, yes, we voted for it by a simple majority, but only just.

The thing is though, that people who were pro-Brexit had a number of different reasons for wanting to leave. Many who were pro-remain have a number of problems with the EU, but believed that leaving would be worse than staying.

The problem seems to be that nobody has a clear picture of what people want from the Brexit, and those orchestrating it have no clear plan. So what to do?

Now bear with me when I say “Another referendum”, because it’s not what you think I mean.

So we’re going to have our employees, the government, negotiate this big deal for us. But will it be what we, the citizens, want?

The way to do it is to require the package of treaties and reforms to be subject to the approval of another referendum. If the citizens are not happy with the package as a whole, it will have to be sent back and renegotiated.

Now some will complain that this means the Brexit is kept in limbo, as we could never agree on anything that the majority of the country will accept. But the argument FOR Brexit is that the majority of the country has asked for this. If Brexit is the thing that the very aggressive pro-Brexit lobby insist that we all want, agreeing on what form this should take should be easy.

So, are they genuine, and angry that people are trying to undermine the will of the people, or are they scared that the narrow margin they won by proves that there is little argument for the Brexit? Are they afraid that without the people who voted to get £350 million for the NHS won’t ascent to the new package? Or that enough people voted “leave” in protest only while wanting to remain, that this will never be approved?

Of course, it’s easier to be belligerent than to argue you are wrong, but if the argument of the Brexiters is genuine, they shouldn’t have any problem with such a process, it just makes sure we can’t water down the Breixt in some way they are unhappy with.

Tuesday, 28 June 2016

A New British Constitution, part 1



The UK has a constitution. Or rather, we have the components of a constitution scattered over various acts and laws. What a mess.

It also is quite poor by way of ensuring our employees (the politicians) behave themselves while running our country. It is thus that I have long been of the opinion that we need a new, properly written, constitution. One that makes it clear to everyone what can be done and how, and what can't be done and when.

Writing any body of ruling, while making it both clear and unambiguous but also strict and well defined, is very, very hard. We don't want anything too specific, but we want it to apply wherever is needed too ensure it's principals.

Thus this is not going to be a single post, but rather forms the introduction to a series of them. I'm going to start with the sorts of principals that we want to enshrine in the constitution:


  • The country is owned by the citizens.
  • The government is employed by the country.
  • The government run things for the benefit of the citizens.
  • A business is not a person.
  • We have a duty of care towards the welfare of the people first and foremost.
  • Public property is held in trust and it's sale needs permission.
  • The right of self-determination is paramount.
  • Our own constitution and laws must trump any treaty or trade agreement we may sight up to.
  • All persons are entitled to equitable treatment by the government, law, and businesses.
  • The individual is free to carry out any act that does not harm others or society.
  • The citizens are entitled to fair and proportional representation.
  • Justice involves rehabilitation rather than just punishment.

The Fine Mess of the Brexit Referendum



So, the referendum.

As many of us knew going in, it was purely advisory, and we still require an act of parliament to actual leave.

The rsults:
37.6% of the electorate voted to Leave
34.5% of the electorate voted to Remain
27.8% of the electorate did not cast a vote

So, just over a third of us, and the largest single group voted to leave.

However, many voted "leave" to get £350 million a week more for the NHS as promised by the Leave campaign. That their representatives have denied ever claiming, and in fact, they'll likely have to cut & privatise it more.

However, many voted "leave" to massively reduce immigration, as promised by the Leave campaign. That their representatives have denied ever claiming, and in fact, the proposed deal with the EU will leave us no different by way of immigration.

However, many voted "leave" to protest the government, in the belief that "Remain" would win anyway. Pretty dumb, but there you go.

So, a plurality of the voters barely scored a win, with a significant number of them only voting that way because of lies told by the Leave campaign, or to protest government policy while actually wanting to remain.

Looking at why so many people where concerned by immigration, beyond the bigots it becomes clear that this is due to public services being stretched by neo-liberal austerity, which has been blamed on immigrants. The solution mooted to the woes being caused by the brexit vote? More neo-liberal austerity!

Claiming that "Leave" won and leaving it at that is oversimplifying the situation to a massive degree. Something needs to be done, that's for sure. However, given the possible "exit" plans don't get what most people voting "Leave" actually wanted, the Brexit is not necessarily it.

Thursday, 16 June 2016

Atheism and Definitions



A friend disagreed with my last post on the point about what Atheism is and is not.

So, to explain, let me take a step back. Most mainstream & moderate* religious people would have a statement of what they do (and do not) believe of the form:
Given that there is, and can, be no evidence either way, and in the very real knowledge that I could be wrong, I have chosen to [specifics].
Examples of [specifics] would be along the lines of “follow [this version] of Christianity”, “follow [this version] of Islam”, etc.

Now we get to Agnosticism. Agnostics, as religious people understand them, generally tend to not have any beliefs for or against the metaphysical. They’re simply not convinced. Thus their statement would be:
Given that there is and can be no evidence either way, and in the very real knowledge that I could be wrong, I have chosen to neither believe nor disbelieve, reserving judgement unless something should change my mind.

And what do the religious folks think Atheism is? Well, it’s one step beyond agnosticism, based on older traditions, and would be along the lines of:
Given that there is and can be no evidence either way, and in the very real knowledge that I could be wrong, I have chosen to believe that there is nothing to the metaphysical.


So far so good. Next we have the modern version of Atheists, who insist that they don’t disbelieve, they just don’t believe . When asked, they would typically say that sufficient evidence would (quite logically) change their mind. Or, to put it another way, they neither believe not disbelieve, reserving judgement unless something should change their mind.

These Atheists would typically fall to the dictionary's definition of Agnosticism; “The belief that knowledge of god and/or the metaphysical is impossible”. By that definition, the statement of beliefs used above would make almost everyone Agnostic by definition, thus not a useful definition.

However, English is descriptively defined, and thus we need not stick to that definition if it is not how it is being used in practice. And this is where there is a problem. What a large majority of “Atheists” believe (or not) these days is exactly the same what the religious folks these days think of as Agnosticism.

And thus we have the problem in that what the religious folk understand as "Agnosticism" and "Atheism" is different from that understood by modern Atheists and some scholars.


*For those who are bound to ask, the extremists claim certain knowledge of the metaphysical, which is impossible by definition. Thus they either do not understand the things they say, do not understand the way the world works, or are, by definition, delusional. Either way they (again by definition) lack faith.

Separation Via A Common Language



I’m going to discuss some aspects of evolution, sexuality, gender, religion, sex, etc here. But first an illustrative aside…

Several years ago, a work colleague approached me excitedly. He’d recently discovered Death Metal, and, knowing I was into Heavy Metal music, asked me if I could perhaps put a CD together with a range of bands for him.

Unfortunately, he hated the CD, full of Death Metal bands (the likes of Decapitated, Vader, Carcass, etc) I made for him. The reason? “This doesn’t sound anything like Lordi!” Yes, Eurovision winners, the Glam Rock band Lordi, is what he’d gotten into. It turned out that some journalist had decided to label them “Death Metal” and he had the wrong idea of commonly accepted terms.


English is defined based on usage. Different groups can use the same word to mean different things and not be wrong. Sometimes, the context can make it clear which meaning is relevant. Sometimes, the various meanings are so close together that you cannot descen the difference from the context. This causes a problem…

Many people have a problem with “Evolution”, but when you look into why they have a problem with it, it becomes clear that their definition of “Evolution” is different from that used in science. What they have a problem with is nothing to do with speciation, which is all that evolution discusses.

A lot more people now refer to themselves as “Atheists” than one did, typically sharing a certain set of beliefs, or lack thereof. Said beliefs, or lack thereof, being those that religious people typically understand as “Agnosticism”.

A lot of people have problems with gay rights, but when you listen to their arguments why, they only makes sense if you define “sexuality” by who a person has sex with, rather than who that person is attracted to. Science used the latter, as does the pro-equal-right lobby.

There are big arguments right now about what toilets, changing rooms, and other ‘facilities’, people use. On one side, people want to limit it to sex-at-birth, to keep men from using the woman’s facilities. Meanwhile, the other side want to base it on gender identity, to keep men from using the woman’s facilities. Both sides using different definitions of “man” and “woman”.

Many people use “Gender” as a synonym for “sex”, since the latter can be confused with the abbreviated form of “sexual intercourse”. Meanwhile, many people use “Gender” as an abbreviation for “gender identity”. At a glance, many sentences discussing gender identity and physical sex are going to use the same general terms.

A lot of people reject Feminism right now. But when asked why, what their rejecting has nothing to do with seeking equity between the sexes, the very definition of Feminism.

Roman Catholic doctrine does not require that sex is only for procreation. Instead it demands a certain minimum chance of conception, since people having sex must be “open to the possibility of life”. Meanwhile, medical science defines any sex act with a certain minimum chance of conception to be “trying for children”. Guess which two definitions are functionally the same?

None of this has the same impact as an elderly relative using “wireless” to refer to the radio rather than the wi-fi, or an idiot journalist calling Lordi a Death Metal band. This lack of clear definition when discussing these things is a serious problem precisely because these differing definitions cause untold strife when trying to move our society forward. It’s funny when an American uses the same terms to refer to different food items. When people can’t agree on what “homosexuality” means, it causes someone to lose their human rights.